NEW YORK -- As the outlook for 2002 improves, analysts continue
to warn investors that some stocks and sectors may already be
factoring in those prospects, CBS MarketWatch.com reports.
Morgan Stanley analyst James Valentine told clients
Wednesday that railroads are already priced for a full recovery,
with stocks such as Burlington Northern Santa Fe, Canadian National,
Canadian Pacific and Union Pacific having already hit his
"post-recession" price targets.
Against that backdrop,
Valentine sliced his "outperform" recommendations on the four
railroads to "neutral," saying he believes the rail stocks are near
the top of their recent run.
Burlington Northern shares
dropped 70 cents, or 2.4 percent, to $28.25; Canadian National fell
$1.02, or 2.2 percent, to $45.82; Union Pacific lost 89 cents, or
1.5 percent, to $58.36; and Canadian Pacific dipped 5 cents to
$20.03.
"Our investment thesis to own the rails was on the
prospect of a cyclical rally, which we expected to occur when signs
of an economic recovery began," Valentine wrote in a research note.
"Although we have yet to see any meaningful pick up in railroad,
trucking or air freight volumes, the financial markets are willing
to support valuation levels that suggest a full economic recovery is
near."
Collectively, he noted, the railroads are within 3
percent of their 20-year peak valuations and are priced for almost
peak operating margins in 2003.
"The results of a
comprehensive shipper survey combined with our industry knowledge
lead us to conclude that we shouldn't expect railroads to exceed
former peak margins any time soon," Valentine said.
In fact,
he said, he could continue recommending the names at this point only
if he believed the industry would exceed best-ever margins in the
next year or two. This, however, seems unrealistic, he said.
Valentine said margin improvement as the economy recovers remains
easy, but that the railroads will continue to face many of the
challenges that have kept earnings growth in check since the
industry was deregulated in 1980.
Valentine acknowledges the
call could be too early and that it was entirely possible valuation
would have no impact on the stocks.
"As with the tech sector
from '97 to '99, news flow can drive stocks more than valuation,
which is possible with the rails as the economy picks up and if oil
prices remain low," Valentine said. "Looking at how well the
railroad stocks rallied before the current recession even began and
then again before there were any signs of an industry recovery,
suggest to us that there may be more focus on the potential
direction of earnings as opposed to the absolute level of earnings
that can be achieved in the next few years."
And even with
the downgrades, Valentine said it doesn't mean investors should sell
out. "We're not against owning a railroad as a long-term stable
investment, but we are cautious about expectations that there be
substantial upside in the near-term."
For investors who must
own a railroad to maintain an S&P weighing in the group,
Valentine recommends Canadian National.
"It is one of the
only carriers to earn its cost of capital and continue to grow its
free cash flow," Valentine said. "Furthermore, CNI received the
highest marks from customers in our recent survey, which suggests
that it has the greatest long-term prospects for growing its top and
bottom lines."