CHICAGO -- Three years ago, state and local officials praised the
Bourbonnais Fire Protection District for its response to a
truck-train crash that killed 11 people aboard an Amtrak Superliner,
reports the Chicago Tribune.
The entire community was
commended for opening its arms--and closets, pantries and
pocketbooks--to more than 100 people taken to hospitals or hotels
and their families.
So on Wednesday, residents and village
officials were stung by a National Transportation Safety Board
report that criticized the department's handling of the
accident.
The board concluded that the trucker ignored
warning lights and bells and drove around lowered crossing gates and
was therefore solely responsible for the crash. But it also said the
Fire Protection District was not prepared to respond effectively to
a passenger train accident like the one on March 15, 1999, that
involved a significant diesel fuel fire.
The rescue effort
was hampered by the lack of a nearby water supply, the safety board
said. But Bourbonnais fire officials compounded the situation by
being slow to request a chemical foam truck to help douse the blaze,
the board said.
Safety board chairman Marion Blakey said it
was fortunate that the interior materials aboard the Amtrak
Superliner were largely non-flammable and did not generate excessive
smoke.
"We had trouble extinguishing the fire," fire chief Ed
St. Louis, who was a captain in 1999, acknowledged Wednesday. "It
was a stubborn, difficult fire to get to."
But St. Louis said
he does not believe the fire district could have done anything that
would have saved more lives.
Residents of the small village
about 50 miles south of Chicago said they continue to be proud of
their emergency workers and the response of the community.
"I
still am totally thrilled with the work of our fire department,"
said Shelly Sparrow, a surgical nurse at Riverside Medical Center in
Kankakee who worked the night of the accident. "All of our emergency
systems responded beautifully."
Rev. Luther Watson, a staff
pastor at College Church of the Nazarene in Bourbonnais, said the
outpouring of support after the crash helped foster a sense of
togetherness still seen today. The night of the accident, dozens of
people helped the Red Cross set up a shelter at a local school, with
dozens more donating clothing, food and money for the victims and
emergency workers.
Some crash victims continued relationships
with Bourbonnais residents, and a one-year memorial service
attracted more than 2,000 people, Watson said.
"This was, I
think, the fire department's first experience ever to face a tragedy
of this size, of this momentum," said Watson, who began counseling
victims that night. "From my standpoint, I really thought the whole
operation jelled together."
At 9:47 p.m. on March 15, 1999,
when most of the district's part- and full-time firefighters were
away from the only fire station, an Amtrak train traveling from
Chicago struck a semi-trailer truck driven by John Stokes of Manteno
at a railroad crossing. The derailing and tremendous fire, stoked by
2,000 gallons of diesel fuel, burned for at least two hours,
officials said.
Fire Lt. Mileen Joines, who worked as an
engineer that night, said that during the 24 minutes it took to
attach a hose into a hydrant a half-mile away, water on the
firetrucks was used to fight the blaze and the trucks never ran out
of water.
More important for putting out the fire was
chemical foam, which has the consistency of dishwashing soap and
turns into suds when pumped to a fire.
At 10:22 p.m., or 23
minutes after the first units arrived on the scene, Bourbonnais
officials requested more foam. But there was not enough available
nearby, and it was not until 10:40 p.m. that Bourbonnais officials
requested a chemical foam truck from refineries south of Joliet, an
hour's drive from the scene, safety board officials said.
By
the time the truck arrived at 11:45 p.m., the fire had consumed the
midsection of the sleeper car, where 11 people were later found
dead, according to the board's report.
Investigators said the
Bourbonnais firefighters, as well as rescue teams from 30
neighboring communities, were unfamiliar with passenger railroad
equipment--particularly regarding how to access damaged or derailed
coach cars and rapidly extricate passengers.
"This type of
training is not costly to do," said safety board spokesman Terry
Williams.
St. Louis said the crash, which thrust the
department of about 42 firefighters into the national spotlight, has
focused the department even more intently on training.
"I
still maintain, and will always maintain, that everybody did a great
job."