ALBANY, N.Y. -- Ongoing difficulties in marrying modern European
train technology to 1970s American-made locomotives have again
delayed high-speed trains that were supposed to start carrying
Capital Region passengers to New York City more than a year ago, the
Albany Times Union reports.
After several setbacks in
production of the first two of seven locomotives to be reconditioned
under a $74.2 million contract with Super Steel Schenectady,
officials with the state Department of Transportation had expected
as recently as December to run comprehensive tests of the fast
trains in January.
Those tests did not take place, however,
and no new date has yet been set for them. DOT is making no
projections on when the trains will be in service.
"When you
are dealing with a technology that is foreign to the United States,
it takes time to work out the bugs,'' said DOT spokesman Peter
Graves. "Things come up as we do diagnostic tests on a lot of
component parts. It's not the kind of thing where we're looking to
beat the clock. We don't want anybody to get on these trains unless
we're 100 percent sure they're the safest way you can travel on a
rail.''
The locomotives being rebuilt were manufactured in
the mid-1970s in California by the Rohr company. The original French
design was adapted to meet American standards and travel on American
tracks.
There are three main design issues now being
addressed by European parts manufacturers and engineers with the
state and Super Steel, Graves said.
The first concern is the
configuration of the control console in the engineer's cab, which
DOT engineers felt needed changes to improve ergonomics and
safety.
Work also is under way to upgrade the "slip-slide
system'' for the wheels, which Graves described as analogous to
anti-lock brakes in an automobile. The initial sensors did not seem
to be consistently tripping the brakes, he said.
Finally, the
air conditioning system was considered too noisy.
"It's not a
cattle car. This is supposed to be a luxury passenger train,''
Graves said.
So far, DOT officials are not expecting the
delays to increase the contract cost with Super Steel -- though
correspondence obtained by the Times Union in November indicated
that Super Steel's Wisconsin parent company, Super Steel Inc., had
begun, in essence, subsidizing the turboliner project, advancing
more than $7 million to the Glenville plant to keep it
operational.
The costs of converting the locomotives, as well
as related infrastructure improvements, are to be shared by the
state, Amtrak and the federal government under a complex formula
that changes as more trains are produced.
Super Steel
Schenectady's general manager, Bill Carr, declined comment last week
on the high-speed train project.
"We're very confident in
Super Steel's ability to live up to the terms of the contract,''
Graves said. "They've done an outstanding job, and we don't consider
them to be the cause of the delay.''
The president of a rail
travel advocacy group said the new delays are more disappointing
than alarming. "From our standpoint, we're continually disappointed
by news of further delays, but we are encouraged that the state
believes this can be resolved,'' said Bruce Becker of the Empire
State Passengers Association.
The gas-powered turboliners
would be the world's fastest non-electric trains and provide a
possible prototype for high-speed rail projects around the country.
Amtrak's Acela Express, the only high-speed rail service now
available in the Northeast, travels only along lines between Boston,
New York City and Washington D.C. and runs on electric
power.
When in service, the rebuilt locomotives are expected
to shave at least 20 minutes off the the 142-mile trip between
Rensselaer and Manhattan, now 2 hours and 25 minutes.
In
addition, plans call for $140 million to be spent on infrastructure
projects, including addition of another track between Albany and
Schenectady, rehabilitation of the Livingston Avenue railroad bridge
in Albany, general track improvements and upgrades to Amtrak's
Rensselaer maintenance facility. DOT and Amtrak officials say some
of those changes should help further speed travel time on the
turboliners.
It's all part of a high-speed rail development
program first announced by Gov. George Pataki in 1998, but there has
been little urgency to complete the infrastructure work until the
first locomotives go into service.
On Thursday, state
Comptroller H. Carl McCall's staff approved a related supplemental
agreement between DOT and Amtrak outlining plans for spending $62
million of the $140 million in infrastructure money, but raised
concerns about whether DOT is ensuring that costs are being shared
according to the formulas agreed upon at the outset by the state,
federal government and Amtrak.
In a letter to Norman R.
Schneider, director of DOT's Freight and Economic Development
Division, Joan M. Sullivan, the comptroller's director of contracts,
said the comptroller's staff has decided to audit project finances
to date.
"We're concerned that they don't appear to be
adequately tracking what is happening,'' said Theresa Bourgeois, a
McCall spokeswoman.
Because it appears the DOT has not kept
up with quarterly "reconciliations,'' records that should update and
verify the money spent from each source for high-speed rail-related
work, the comptroller's staff has not been able to determine whether
costs are being shared according to plan, Bourgeois
said.
Melissa Carlson, a DOT spokeswoman, said the agency
"welcomes the review as long as it's done in a nonpartisan,
professional manner.''