The Teamsters strike
against the United Parcel Service has been a long time
coming. Americans used to get a decent job and keep it
for life. Then it became successive jobs--usually each an
improvement over the prior one. Next, it was successive
jobs, only this time headed back down the wage ladder.
Now it can be three or four jobs all at the same time,
with none by itself paying a livable wage or benefits.
Today one-fourth of the workforce--or about 20 million
workers--is in a part-time job. Up to another 18 million
work in temporary or contingent jobs, or as independent
contractors. A study to be released next month by the
Economic Policy Institute will show that this latter
group is growing in size.
The exact number of part-timers is a little hard to pin
down because federal government surveys only define
part-time work as 35 hours a week or less. Thus, workers,
like those at UPS, who are forced to work full-time
hours, don't show up in the government tallies. Sure,
they may be paid overtime, but that isn't based on a
full-time wage, nor are their benefits increased to those
of full-timers. And, of course, workers who hold more
than one job--all of which are part time--aren't counted
either.
Nonetheless, it is telling that Manpower, a temp service,
is the country's largest employer and growing. Right now,
part-timers are concentrated in health care and other
service industries. Nearly 12 percent of the
transportation industry, including UPS is part time. But
pockets can be found across industries, at every skill
and education level.
Big corporations love these throw-away jobs. Forget the
claims by UPS and other employers that workers want it
this way: few of them do. About 7 million Americans--or
about a third of all part-timers--say they would prefer a
full-time position. These workers are forced to take
part-time work with low wages and few benefits because
that's all employers are offering.
According to one researcher, involuntary part-timers
live, on the average, on incomes at least $17,000 below
those who want to work part-time.
That means the part-time life is great for those who want
it--students, parents of young children and the
semi-retired--but for the rest it's tough luck. And make
no mistake about it, employers, in general, aren't trying
to accommodate the family and other needs of their
employees in creating or scheduling part-time jobs.
Instead, they are simply trying to cut costs and increase
profits.
According to the Labor Department, the average hourly
wage for full-time workers was $10.85, compared with
$7.54 for part-time workers. Companies may be saving
money up front, but they are creating a restless and
non-loyal workforce. One study found that turnover at UPS
was 150 percent--with many citing the lack of full-time
openings as the reason for quitting. It costs money to
hire and train people, regardless of how
"unskilled" employers consider some positions.
Full-timers can't count themselves blessed in this
quicksand of secure incomes. Besides wage erosion, their
benefits are also slowly slipping away. In the past four
years, the Bureau of Labor Statistics found that coverage
for defined-benefit pension plans, paid holidays, paid
sick leave and health care is steadily dropping. Of those
who get health care, many are being forced into health
maintenance organizations.
The UPS may be the first major strike around the issue of
part-time workers. But we all have already grappled with
the problem. We fight against the
"competitiveness" claim in each round of
negotiations we enter as union employers want to drop
costs to the wages and benefits of this new labor pool.
This may be the most visible stand yet, but it won't
last. You can count on it. |